Recover Failed Payments with Smart Dunning
Your Brand Here
Get an X shoutout, video mention, dofollow backlink, plus banner visibility on all experiments and comparison pages. Reach B2B buyers actively researching churn solutions.
The Problem
15-35% of SMB SaaS customers churn due to involuntary payment failures. Most companies send generic retry emails that get ignored.
The Solution
Implement a 3-tier dunning sequence with personalized messaging, in-app alerts, and payment method updates. Use behavioral triggers based on customer value and engagement.
Implementation Steps
-
1
Set up payment retry logic with your payment processor (3 attempts over 7 days)
-
2
Create email sequence: Day 0 (friendly reminder), Day 3 (urgent notice with easy update link), Day 6 (final notice with phone number)
-
3
Add in-app banner for logged-in users with failed payments
-
4
Implement SMS notifications for high-value customers (>$500 MRR)
-
5
Track dunning recovery rates and iterate on messaging
Expected Outcome
Recover 40-60% of failed payments, reduce involuntary churn by 8-12%
How to Measure Success
Track these metrics to know if the experiment is working:
- Baseline involuntary churn rate before implementation
- Payment recovery rate (target: 40-60% of failed payments)
- Reduction in involuntary churn (target: 8-12 percentage points)
- Email open rates for dunning sequence (benchmark: 35-45%)
- Conversion rate from dunning emails to successful payment
- Average time to payment recovery
Prerequisites
Make sure you have these before starting:
- Payment processor with retry logic capability (Stripe, Braintree, etc.)
- Email service provider with automation (Customer.io, Intercom, etc.)
- Ability to track payment failure events
- At least 50+ monthly payment failures to measure impact
- Legal approval for payment retry timing in your jurisdictions
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Don't make these errors that cause experiments to fail:
- Being too aggressive with retry timing - space attempts 2-3 days apart, not daily
- Using generic "payment failed" language - specify the exact card/payment issue
- Not offering alternative payment methods in the email sequence
- Sending the same message in all emails - escalate urgency gradually
- Forgetting to pause retries if customer manually cancels
- Not testing with different card decline codes (each needs different messaging)
Related Experiments
Competitive Displacement Prevention Program
Customers switch to competitors when they see better pricing, features, or sales pitches. 40% of chu...
Ship Retention Experiments in 15 Days Instead of Months
Most churn ideas die before they get tested. Not because they are bad ideas, but because they requir...
Onboarding Activation Milestones for B2B Products
40-60% of B2B SaaS trials never reach activation. Users sign up, get overwhelmed, and never experien...
More ways to reduce churn
Explore more experiments or browse our tool directory